Local business? Support local news on QueenCreek.city

Back to Queen Creek

Chief justice calls loss of three judges in retention votes 'devastating' and plans a review before 2028

Initial results show voters declined to retain an Arizona Court of Appeals judge and two Maricopa County Superior Court judges; Chief Justice Ann Scott Timmer says the system needs changes.

Briar Doyle· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 16, 20262 min read

Judicial System Review - illustration, Jake Team LLC

Arizona voters appear to have removed three judges from the bench in the Nov. 3 retention elections, and the state's chief justice says the system that put them on the ballot needs fixing, Capitol Media Services reported through the Daily Independent.

The margins are from initial, unofficial results:

  • Anni Hill Foster, Arizona Court of Appeals, appointed by then-Gov. Doug Ducey in 2022 and facing voters for the first time: 50.2% voted no (525,834) and 49.8% voted yes (521,612).
  • Julie Mata, Maricopa County Superior Court: about 51.3% no and 48.7% yes. She was retained with 75.8% in 2022.
  • Michael Rassas, Maricopa County Superior Court: about 50.6% no and 49.4% yes. He was retained with 69.5% in 2022.

The chief justice's response

Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Ann Scott Timmer said, "Losing these three judges is devastating." She described the retention system as "broken" and said she plans to form a committee to study this year's results and propose changes before the 2028 election, when she is on the ballot herself, according to the report.

William Auther, who chairs the Commission on Judicial Performance Review, told the outlet, "None of it makes any sense to me, honestly."

The other side

Cathy Sigmon, founder of the voter guide Gavel Watch, which opposed Foster and Mata and raised concerns about Rassas, said her group is watching for patterns: "We want to see a trend line," she told the outlet.

The report also named the Maricopa County Republican Committee, Legislative District 4 Republicans, the Arizona Free Enterprise Club and a political action committee, Arizonans for Judicial Accountability, among groups active in the races.

Arizona's merit selection system covers Supreme Court justices, Court of Appeals judges and Superior Court judges in Maricopa, Pima, Pinal and Coconino counties, the report said. In 2024, voters rejected a measure to limit retention elections, with 77.7% voting no.

Source: https://www.yourvalley.net/stories/chief-justice-speaks-out-after-arizona-voters-oust-3-judges,741134

Sources

yourvalley.net

Share

Briar Doyle· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Briar Doyle covers Queen Creek city hall, the council, and county government.

Related Stories

More in Arizona