Local business? Support local news on QueenCreek.city

Back to Queen Creek

Felony count tossed in a Gilbert case after police used AI to draft the arrest narrative

A Maricopa County commissioner kept two misdemeanors but said the evidence carried limited weight; Gilbert police say officers review every Axon Draft One report for accuracy.

Pierce Keller· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 20, 20262 min read

AI Justice Review - illustration, Jake Team LLC

A Maricopa County judicial officer has thrown out a felony charge in a Gilbert police case and questioned how much weight to give the evidence, because officers had relied on artificial intelligence in drafting the probable cause statement, AZFamily reported Friday. It is the second case in a few weeks in which the same commissioner has raised the issue.

According to AZFamily, Gilbert officers went to a house close to Pecos and Higley roads, where, investigators said, a woman armed with a knife threatened relatives, who shut themselves in a room and dialed 911.

At her initial appearance, the commissioner dismissed a felony aggravated assault charge, pointing to a line in the report that said no specific threats about the knife or bodily harm had been reported. The commissioner let two misdemeanor counts proceed.

"Although probable cause was found, the weight of the evidence is limited, given that there is limited information provided about the extent of the usage and contribution of generative artificial intelligence that was used in drafting the arrest narrative allegations," the commissioner said, as quoted by AZFamily.

The concern centered on the report's final paragraph, which disclosed that AI had been used to write the statement. In the earlier case, the same judicial officer released a DUI suspect for the same reason; that arrest was made by the Arizona Department of Public Safety, the station reported.

What Gilbert police say

Gilbert police told AZFamily the department uses Axon Draft One and has for more than a year. "The content of the narratives is based on body-worn camera recordings and officers' input in the narratives. Officers are required to review and verify that all information in the report is accurate," the department said.

Outside views

Katie Kinsey of the Policing Project at NYU Law School told the station she was not surprised and that such questions are coming up more often in policing. She described a probable cause statement, which justifies an arrest, search or other enforcement action, as "a really high-risk document" because it affects someone's liberty.

Jonathan Wroblewski, a senior fellow with the Council on Criminal Justice, told AZFamily that AI output is not automatically reliable. He said having an officer or detective review a report is one step toward making it reliable, but that other steps are probably needed as well.

Sources

azfamily.com

Share

Pierce Keller· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Pierce Keller writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Queen Creek.

Related Stories

More in Arizona