Back to Sport

Smith's pinch-hit walk-off homer lifts D-backs over Yankees

Pavin Smith hit a two-run walk-off homer in the ninth off Michael Fulmer as Arizona beat New York 5-3 and moved within four games of the final NL wild card.

Queen Creek Newsroom

September 20, 20263 min read

Symbolic baseball trophy emblem in a desert twilight stadium setting, no athletes
MLBFinal
New York Yankees3
Arizona Diamondbacks5

September 19, 2026

PHOENIX - Pavin Smith waited on the bench until the ninth, then ended the night with one swing that pulled Arizona back into the wild-card conversation.

Smith, pinch-hitting after Ildemaro Vargas walked to open the ninth, drove a two-run homer into the right-field seats off Michael Fulmer for a 5-3 walk-off win over the New York Yankees on Saturday at Chase Field. ESPN's box lists Smith 1-for-1 with a run, two RBIs and the home run - 391 feet to right-center, per the play-by-play.

The Associated Press called it a cutter Fulmer left over the plate after Vargas won an ABS challenge on a full-count pitch initially called a strike.

Walk-off on an anniversary night

Jordan Lawlar had struck out between Vargas' walk and Smith's at-bat. Smith still delivered Arizona had trailed 3-2 after the sixth and found a way in the ninth. The franchise was celebrating the 25th anniversary of its 2001 World Series win over these same Yankees, the AP noted, when Smith sent Chase Field home happy.

Arizona improved to 81-74 and pulled within four games of Philadelphia for the final National League wild card with seven games remaining, snapping a three-game losing streak. New York fell to 89-65 and absorbed its 11th walk-off loss, one behind San Francisco for the major league lead.

How the game reached the ninth

Cam Schlittler worked six innings for New York and allowed three runs, only one earned, lowering his ERA to 1.94. A throwing error on Tim Tawa's bunt attempt opened the door for Lawlar's two-run triple in the fifth. Austin Wells and Heliot Ramos homered off Kevin Ginkel in the sixth to put the Yankees ahead 3-2.

Corbin Carroll's sacrifice fly tied it in the bottom half before Schlittler struck out the side of the threat.

Brandon Pfaadt started for Arizona and gave up one run on four hits and a walk over 4 1/3 innings with three strikeouts. Juan Morillo (1-1) earned the win with 1 1/3 hitless innings. Fulmer (0-1) faced two batters in the ninth and allowed the walk and the homer.

Sunday and the scramble

Smith's average sits well below the lineup's heart, which is why he was available on the bench for a pinch-hit spot instead of starting against Schlittler. That is also why a 1-for-1 with a walk-off carries weight in a seven-game sprint: Arizona cannot wait for every regular to heat up at once. Vargas' ABS challenge set the table; Smith's cutter to the seats cleared it.

With Burnes scheduled Sunday, the D-backs still have to win their share - but they no longer sit on a three-game skid with the Yankees in town.

Attendance was 47,918. The game lasted 2 hours, 48 minutes. Corbin Burnes (0-0, 5.87 ERA) is listed for Arizona on Sunday against Will Warren (10-6, 3.89) for New York. Smith's pinch-hit swing turned a lost lead into a kept season - seven games left, four back, and suddenly loud again in the desert.

Sources

ESPN

ESPN

CBS Sports

Share

Queen Creek Newsroom

Reporting from Queen Creek and the surrounding area.

Related Stories

More in Weather